Sold · November 16, 2026
61 N Cartwright Road
New York 11964, Shelter Island, NY
$2,175,000
Rank in New York
#5
of 6 sales in 2026
Price per sq ft
$667
Sale vs. asking
−2.5%
asked $2.23M
A 5-bedroom house in 11964 closed for $2.17 million, about $667 per square foot. The 3,262-square-foot home, built in 1858, spent 39 days on the market and sold 2.5% under its last asking price of $2.23 million.
- Type
- House
- Bedrooms
- 5
- Bathrooms
- 4
- Interior
- 3,262 sq ft
- Lot
- 43,560 sq ft
- Built
- 1858
- Days on market
- 39
- Last asking
- $2,230,000
- Closed
- November 16, 2026